California’s Racial Justice Act, codified in Penal Code section 745, allows defendants to challenge criminal charges, convictions, and sentences involving prohibited racial bias. The law addresses discriminatory conduct, racially discriminatory trial language, and certain disparities in charging or sentencing. A defendant does not have to prove intentional discrimination to establish a violation.
For someone facing criminal charges or living with an older conviction, the Act may provide an important path to relief. However, an allegation of unfair treatment does not automatically establish a Racial Justice Act violation. The claim must satisfy the law’s requirements and have factual support.
The practical questions are who qualifies, what evidence can establish a violation, and which procedure applies to the case.
Key Takeaways
- California Penal Code section 745 prohibits specified forms of racial bias in criminal proceedings. Violations can involve discriminatory conduct, language, charging decisions, or sentencing disparities.
- Intentional discrimination is not required. However, the defendant must establish one of the violations recognized by the statute.
- The Racial Justice Act can apply before or after conviction. Different procedures govern trial court motions, direct appeals, habeas petitions, and motions to vacate.
- Beginning January 1, 2026, qualifying older felony convictions are covered by the Act’s expanded retroactivity provisions, regardless of when the judgment became final.
- Relief depends on the violation and procedural circumstances. A successful claim may result in new proceedings, modification of a conviction, resentencing, or another authorized remedy. Special rules govern older judgments and death-penalty cases.
Who Can File a California Racial Justice Act Claim?
A person facing criminal charges, appealing a conviction, or seeking post-conviction relief may be eligible to bring a Racial Justice Act (RJA) claim when the facts support a violation of Penal Code section 745.
The law covers specified forms of racial bias involving criminal proceedings, charging decisions, convictions, and sentencing.
Beginning January 1, 2026, the Act’s phased retroactivity provisions extend the specified post-conviction procedures to felony convictions regardless of when the judgment became final.
However, eligibility to bring a claim does not guarantee relief. The defendant or petitioner must satisfy the applicable procedural requirements and establish a statutory violation.
The appropriate legal process depends on whether the criminal case is pending, on direct appeal, or already final, as well as the person’s custody status.
What Counts as a Racial Justice Act Violation?
Penal Code section 745 identifies four categories of violations. Understanding the differences matters because a claim involving discriminatory statements requires different evidence from a claim involving unequal charging or sentencing.
Racial Bias Directed at the Defendant
Section 745(a)(1) addresses bias or animus toward a defendant because of the defendant’s race, ethnicity, or national origin.
It covers conduct by a judge, an attorney in the case, a law enforcement officer involved in the case, an expert witness, or a juror.
This provision is not limited to prosecutors. It can also apply to defense attorneys or qualifying law enforcement conduct during an investigation.
However, the evidence must establish the required connection to the defendant and the case—not merely a general concern about racial bias in the criminal justice system.
For example, statements demonstrating racial hostility during an investigation may warrant examination under the Act. Whether those statements establish a violation depends on their content, context, and relationship to the defendant.
Racially Discriminatory Language During Trial
Section 745(a)(2) addresses racially discriminatory language or other qualifying bias by specified trial participants during the defendant’s trial, in court and during the proceedings.
Under section 745(h)(4), racially discriminatory language includes language that, from an objective observer’s perspective, explicitly or implicitly appeals to racial bias.
The statutory definition identifies racially charged or coded language, comparisons of the defendant to an animal, and references to the defendant’s physical appearance, culture, ethnicity, or national origin.
Whether particular language violates the Act depends on its context and whether it objectively appeals to racial bias. The statute does not require proof that the speaker intentionally discriminated.
In People v. Demolle (2026) 19 Cal.5th 1117, an Alameda County case, the California Supreme Court examined animal-related descriptions used during penalty-phase argument.
The Court concluded that referring to the defendant as a “predator” and a “wolf in sheep’s clothing” did not violate the Act in context. As to other references to the defendant as a “wolf,” the Court assumed without deciding that a violation occurred but found any error harmless beyond a reasonable doubt.
The decision illustrates an important distinction: although the statute expressly identifies animal comparisons as potentially discriminatory language, not every animal comparison establishes a violation. Courts must consider the language in context under the objective-observer standard.
More Serious Charges or Convictions
Section 745(a)(3) addresses situations in which a defendant was charged with or convicted of a more serious offense than similarly situated defendants of other races, ethnicities, or national origins who engaged in similar conduct.
The claim must also establish a county-level pattern: prosecutors more frequently sought or obtained more serious convictions against people sharing the defendant’s race, ethnicity, or national origin.
A different outcome in one other person’s case does not, by itself, establish both requirements.
Longer or More Severe Sentences
Section 745(a)(4) addresses a longer or more severe sentence than those imposed on similarly situated individuals convicted of the same offense, together with the required county-level sentencing pattern.
The pattern may concern the defendant’s race, ethnicity, or national origin. It may also involve differences associated with the race, ethnicity, or national origin of victims in the compared cases.
The statute requires more than identifying a harsh sentence or a general demographic imbalance. The defense must establish the relevant statutory comparisons and disparities.
How Can the Racial Justice Act Be Used Before Trial?
A defendant does not have to wait for a conviction to raise an RJA claim.
When qualifying evidence arises while a criminal case is pending, the defense may file a motion under Penal Code section 745 and seek relevant records through discovery.
Timing matters. A motion made at trial must be raised as soon as practicable after the defendant learns of the alleged violation. An untimely motion may be deemed waived.
A Bay Area criminal defense attorney can assess whether the available facts support a motion, whether additional records are needed, and how an RJA issue fits alongside other defenses.
For example, a defense investigation may examine whether recorded statements, police reports, or other evidence support an allegation that racial bias affected how officers treated the accused.
The task is to connect specific evidence to a statutory violation rather than rely on a broad accusation of unfairness.
In Hernandez v. Superior Court (2025), a case arising in Santa Clara County, the Court of Appeal ordered an evidentiary hearing on an RJA claim involving allegations of racial profiling by law enforcement.
That ruling allowed the claim to be examined at a hearing; it did not itself establish that a violation had occurred.
Additional Requirements for Claims Involving Police Conduct
Changes effective January 1, 2026, created additional service requirements for certain RJA claims involving law enforcement officers.
When a defendant is represented by an attorney and a section 745 motion alleges a violation of section 745(a)(1) or (a)(2) based in whole or in part on an officer’s conduct, the attorney must serve a copy of the motion on the law enforcement agency or agencies that employed the officer or officers.
Related service requirements apply to certain RJA habeas petitions and motions to vacate convictions.
These requirements do not change the substantive definition of an RJA violation, but they make compliance with applicable filing and service procedures important.
Can the Racial Justice Act Challenge an Existing Conviction?
Yes. The RJA is not limited to pending criminal cases. It can also support qualifying challenges after conviction, making it an important consideration when evaluating post-conviction relief in California.
The correct procedure depends on the case’s status, the person’s custody status, and whether the necessary evidence already appears in the trial record.
Direct Appeals, Habeas Corpus, and Motions to Vacate
Direct appeal: A defendant may raise an RJA claim based on the trial record on direct appeal from the conviction or sentence. When additional factual development is needed, the defendant may seek a stay of the appeal and a remand to the superior court to pursue a section 745 motion.
Habeas corpus: Penal Code section 1473(e) provides a procedure for raising RJA violations through a habeas petition. This may be an appropriate route for a person who remains in criminal custody and satisfies the applicable requirements.
Motion to vacate: A person who is no longer in criminal custody may be able to challenge a conviction or sentence under Penal Code section 1473.7(a)(3), which specifically addresses Racial Justice Act violations.
That last procedure is distinct from the immigration-related ground discussed in our guide to PC 1473.7 motions based on immigration-related error.
Both fall under section 1473.7, but they require different legal showings. An RJA claim under subdivision (a)(3) is not limited to establishing an immigration-related error.
Does California’s Racial Justice Act Apply to Old Convictions in 2026?
Beginning January 1, 2026, the RJA’s phased retroactivity provisions reach felony convictions regardless of when the judgment became final, through the specified post-conviction procedures.
The expansion also covers qualifying juvenile dispositions that resulted in commitment to the Division of Juvenile Justice.
An older felony conviction is therefore not automatically excluded merely because it became final many years ago.
However, this does not mean every older conviction must be reopened or that relief is automatic.
Older misdemeanor cases require a separate eligibility analysis under the statute’s other provisions. The 2026 felony expansion does not automatically extend to every old misdemeanor judgment.
Filing requirements also remain important. For example, an RJA motion under section 1473.7 must be brought without undue delay after the supporting evidence was discovered or reasonably could have been discovered.
How Do You Prove a Racial Justice Act Violation?
The evidence depends on the alleged violation.
A discriminatory-language claim may center on a transcript, recording, or statements made during proceedings. A charging-disparity claim usually requires information about comparable cases and the relevant county’s practices.
The defendant must ultimately establish the violation by a preponderance of the evidence, but lower evidentiary thresholds apply when requesting discovery or seeking an evidentiary hearing.
Evidence From the Defendant’s Own Case
Potentially useful materials include recordings, police reports, court transcripts, correspondence, and declarations from people with firsthand knowledge of relevant conduct.
Published RJA decisions illustrate how statements, investigative records, and supporting declarations can become part of the factual showing.
A useful starting point is specificity:
- What was said or done?
- Who was involved?
- When did the alleged conduct occur?
- Is there a recording, transcript, or document?
- What connects the conduct to race, ethnicity, or national origin?
For example, “the officer was biased” is a conclusion. Identifying particular statements, preserving the complete recording, and explaining their context gives an attorney something concrete to investigate.
What Documents Should Someone Gather for an RJA Case Review?
A person considering an RJA claim may benefit from preserving and organizing available materials before speaking with an attorney.
Useful records may include:
- Police reports and available body-camera or other recordings
- Charging documents, plea agreements, and sentencing records
- Trial transcripts and relevant court orders
- Exact statements allegedly demonstrating racial bias
- Information about potentially comparable criminal cases
- The conviction date and procedural history
- Information about current custody status and prior appeals or petitions
Not every case requires each of these materials, and not every document will be available to the defendant.
The purpose of gathering records is to identify a potentially supportable legal claim—not to assume that the existence of any particular document establishes a violation.
Comparable Cases and County-Level Evidence
For charging and sentencing claims, the comparisons must address legally relevant similarities.
Depending on the claim, that can include the conduct, offense, criminal history, sentencing circumstances, and relevant time period.
In People v. Superior Court (Davis) (2026), the Court of Appeal rejected a discovery showing involving inadequately matched comparison groups and other evidentiary deficiencies.
The decision illustrates that even a discovery request, which requires a lower showing than final proof, must be supported by a plausible factual foundation.
Broad statistics or comparisons that overlook important differences may not be enough.
For a case in Alameda County, for example, the statute’s county-based requirements make relevant Alameda County evidence especially important. Data from elsewhere may provide context but do not automatically establish the required local pattern.
The law does not require comparison cases to be identical, and formal statistical significance is not always necessary.
Courts consider the totality of the evidence, including whether genuine race-neutral reasons explain a disparity and whether systemic or institutional racial bias affected the data.
Discovery Can Help Obtain Records the Defense Does Not Have
The defense does not have to prove the entire RJA claim before requesting relevant records in the possession or control of the state.
A discovery motion must identify the type of requested information and establish good cause.
In Young v. Superior Court (2022), the Court of Appeal explained that good cause requires a plausible factual foundation, based on specific facts, that an RJA violation could or might have occurred.
This is a lower threshold than the showing required for an evidentiary hearing.
Discovery is not unlimited. Courts can address relevance, burden, privacy, and privilege through restrictions on requests, redactions, protective orders, or other statutory safeguards.
Changes effective in 2026 also clarified discovery procedures for RJA habeas petitions.
In In re Haney (2026), the Court of Appeal recognized that a person may request RJA discovery while preparing a habeas petition, before filing the petition itself.
The petitioner need not first establish a prima facie claim to seek discovery. However, the request remains subject to the applicable good-cause and disclosure requirements.
Discovery, a Hearing, and Relief Require Different Showings
These stages should not be confused:
| Stage | Required showing |
|---|---|
| Obtaining RJA discovery | Good cause supported by a plausible factual foundation that a violation could or might have occurred |
| Establishing a prima facie RJA claim | Facts that, if true, show a substantial likelihood of a violation—more than a mere possibility, but less than “more likely than not” |
| Proving the violation | A preponderance of the evidence, meaning the violation is more likely than not |
These distinctions matter in both PC 745 motions and RJA habeas proceedings.
A court should not demand full proof of a violation merely to decide whether a lower-threshold procedural step is available.
The Nieves Law Firm
Your Future Is
Worth Fighting For
If you or someone you care about is facing criminal charges in the Bay Area, the next decision matters. Call us for a confidential consultation.
100% Confidential
Se Habla Español
Payment Plans Available
What Makes a California Racial Justice Act Claim Difficult to Prove?
RJA claims often require more than demonstrating that someone experienced an unfavorable result in the criminal justice system.
The defense must identify a statutory violation and support it with evidence relevant to that particular claim.
Three common challenges are especially important.
First, discriminatory conduct must be evaluated in context. A particular statement may raise concerns about bias without necessarily satisfying the statute’s objective standards.
Second, statistical comparisons must account for legally relevant differences. Defendants who appear similar may have different criminal histories, charges, conduct, or sentencing circumstances. Those differences can affect whether a comparison supports an RJA claim.
Third, procedural requirements can determine how and when the claim is heard. A potentially meritorious claim may still require compliance with filing deadlines, discovery rules, service requirements, and the correct post-conviction procedure.
The practical question is not simply whether a criminal case involved unfairness. It is whether the available facts establish one of the violations recognized by Penal Code section 745 and whether the appropriate procedure is available to pursue relief.
Attorney Insight: The Most Important Evidence May Be Outside the Police Report
By Jo-Anna Nieves, Esq., Founder and Managing Attorney of The Nieves Law Firm
When evaluating a potential Racial Justice Act claim, I believe attorneys must ask questions that go beyond whether the defendant was subjected to an explicit racial slur or openly discriminatory statement.
The Racial Justice Act allows the defense to examine certain disparities in charging decisions, convictions, and sentencing, as well as other forms of prohibited bias. But identifying a concern and establishing an actionable statutory violation are different things.
Our firm has pursued Racial Justice Act discovery in litigation as part of a broader strategy that included investigating the prosecution’s evidence and preparing other pretrial challenges. That experience reinforces why discovery can be so important: the information needed to evaluate a claim may not already be contained in the documents initially produced by the prosecution.
I believe defense counsel should investigate potential RJA issues early, identify the specific statutory theory, and determine what evidence is needed to support the claim.
The absence of an obvious discriminatory statement does not mean there is nothing to investigate. But a legally persuasive RJA claim must ultimately be grounded in evidence, not assumptions.
Can a Racial Justice Act Claim Get Charges or a Conviction Dismissed?
A successful RJA claim does not automatically result in an acquittal or permanent dismissal of the criminal case.
The remedy depends on the type of violation, the procedural stage, and applicable statutory limitations.
Remedies Before Judgment
Since January 1, 2026, when a court finds a violation before judgment, section 745(e)(1) requires it to impose a remedy specific to the violation; before the 2026 amendments, the statute said the court “may” do so. The available remedies include:
- Granting the defendant’s request for a mistrial
- Discharging the jury panel and selecting a new jury
- Dismissing enhancements, special circumstances, or special allegations, or reducing charges when the interests of justice support that remedy
- Imposing another remedy not prohibited by law
These remedies are designed to address the particular violation while operating within the statute’s requirements.
Remedies After Judgment
When a conviction was sought or obtained in violation of the Act, section 745(e)(2) generally requires the court to vacate the conviction and sentence and order new proceedings consistent with the Act, subject to applicable statutory limitations.
If the only established violation is a charging-or-conviction disparity under section 745(a)(3), the statute also permits the court to modify the judgment to a lesser included or lesser related offense.
If the violation affected only the sentence, the remedy may instead involve vacating the sentence and imposing a new sentence.
A new sentence imposed through the RJA resentencing process cannot exceed the previously imposed sentence.
However, setting aside a conviction does not necessarily end the prosecution. Additional proceedings may follow.
What Happens to a Death Sentence After an RJA Violation?
Penal Code section 745(l) provides that when a court finds a violation of section 745(a), the defendant is ineligible for the death penalty. However, the California Supreme Court has interpreted this provision in light of constitutional limitations and the procedural circumstances of the case.
In People v. Bankston (2026) 19 Cal.5th 786, the California Supreme Court found a violation of section 745(a)(2) arising from the prosecutor’s penalty-phase closing argument. Considering the argument as a whole, the Court concluded that it implicitly appealed to racial bias. The violation was not harmless beyond a reasonable doubt, and the Court reversed the death judgment while affirming the judgment in other respects.
The Court also held that section 745(l)’s death-penalty ineligibility applies to the proceeding in which the violation was found. It does not permanently bar the prosecution from seeking the death penalty in a subsequent penalty-phase retrial. Accordingly, the prosecution could elect to retry the penalty phase on remand.
In People v. Barrera (2026) 19 Cal.5th 919, decided the same day as Bankston, the California Supreme Court further clarified that section 745(l) does not require automatic reversal of every death judgment based on an RJA violation without regard to prejudice.
For judgments entered before the RJA took effect, violations involving the use of facially neutral language that implicitly appeals to racial bias are not reversible if the prosecution establishes that the error was harmless beyond a reasonable doubt.
The Court interpreted section 745(l) narrowly to avoid serious constitutional questions involving two sources of law: article VI, section 13 of the California Constitution, which limits reversal to errors resulting in a miscarriage of justice, and the 1978 Briggs Initiative (Proposition 7), which established aspects of California’s death-penalty framework and cannot be amended by the Legislature acting alone.
Together, Bankston and Barrera establish that the availability of death-penalty relief under the RJA depends on the nature of the violation, whether the error was prejudicial, and the procedural circumstances. A finding of an RJA violation does not necessarily create permanent ineligibility for the death penalty or require automatic reversal of an existing death judgment.
A Special Rule for Certain Pre-2021 Judgments
For petitions involving judgments entered before January 1, 2021, section 745(k) establishes a special rule for claims under section 745(a)(1) or (a)(2).
Under that provision, a qualifying petitioner is entitled to relief unless the state proves beyond a reasonable doubt that the violation did not contribute to the judgment.
In People v. Bankston (2026) 19 Cal.5th 786 and People v. Barrera (2026) 19 Cal.5th 919, the California Supreme Court addressed harmless-error review for RJA claims involving judgments entered before the Act took effect.
In Bankston and Barrera, both automatic appeals from death judgments entered before the RJA took effect, the California Supreme Court held that the use of language implicitly appealing to racial bias is not grounds for reversal if the People prove it was harmless beyond a reasonable doubt. Section 745(k) prescribes that standard for habeas petitions in pre-2021 cases, and the Court held it does not foreclose harmless-error review on direct appeal. In Bankston, the violation was not harmless and the death judgment was reversed. In Barrera, the Court found no violation as to some claims and held any remaining error harmless. The Court expressly declined to decide whether other types of RJA claims, or claims in cases tried after the Act took effect, are subject to harmless-error review.
These decisions establish that qualifying RJA claims involving older judgments may require harmless-error analysis rather than automatic reversal. The applicable remedy depends on the statutory provision, procedural posture, and whether the prosecution can satisfy its burden of demonstrating harmlessness.
Frequently Asked Questions About California’s Racial Justice Act
Do You Need an Explicit Racial Slur to Establish a Violation?
No. The Act reaches certain implicit appeals to racial bias as well as explicit discrimination.
Under section 745(h)(4), potentially discriminatory language includes racially charged or coded language, animal comparisons, and certain references to the defendant’s appearance, culture, ethnicity, or national origin.
However, the absence of an intent requirement does not eliminate the need for evidence.
As People v. Demolle illustrates, courts evaluate the language and surrounding circumstances rather than automatically treating every offensive statement or animal comparison as an RJA violation.
Can You Bring an RJA Claim After Pleading Guilty or No Contest?
Potentially, yes.
A plea does not automatically exclude a conviction from RJA review.
Section 1473.7 provides a racial-justice ground for relief for eligible people no longer in criminal custody and addresses withdrawal of a guilty or no-contest plea when the court grants relief.
The person must still establish eligibility and a qualifying violation.
Can the Court Appoint an Attorney for an RJA Habeas Petition?
Yes, when the statutory requirements are satisfied.
Under Penal Code section 1473(e), the court must appoint counsel for a petitioner who cannot afford counsel if the petition pleads a plausible RJA violation or the State Public Defender requests appointment.
The 2026 amendments adopted this “plausible allegation” standard, replacing the earlier requirement that the petition allege facts that would establish a violation. In our view, it is a lower bar than the prima facie showing required for the court to issue an order to show cause, though the statute does not expressly compare the two.
Appointment of counsel does not itself establish that the conviction is invalid.
Does Racial Discrimination During Jury Selection Violate the RJA?
Not necessarily. Discriminatory jury selection may violate constitutional or statutory protections without establishing a claim cognizable under the Racial Justice Act.
In People v. Hazlett (2026) 20 Cal.5th 904, modified on denial of rehearing November 10, 2026, the California Supreme Court held that the RJA does not apply to the exercise of a peremptory challenge against a prospective juror.
The Court also concluded that the defendant’s claim concerning the prosecutor’s questioning of a prospective juror, standing alone, was not cognizable under the RJA.
The modification did not affect the judgment.
Separate protections against discriminatory jury selection remain available under the federal and California constitutions and, where applicable, California Code of Civil Procedure section 231.7.
A separate RJA claim may still arise from conduct that independently satisfies Penal Code section 745, including qualifying bias by a seated juror or another covered trial participant.
Does the Racial Justice Act Apply to Cases Outside the Bay Area?
Yes.
The Racial Justice Act is a statewide California law. It is not limited to Oakland, Alameda County, or the Bay Area.
However, certain charging and sentencing claims require evidence of disparities within the county where the relevant prosecution or sentencing occurred.
That local evidentiary requirement is distinct from the law’s statewide applicability.
Does Filing an RJA Claim Automatically Stop a Criminal Case?
No.
Filing an RJA motion or petition does not automatically establish a violation, dismiss charges, vacate a conviction, or guarantee a stay of proceedings.
The court must consider the procedural posture, the defendant’s showing, and the applicable legal requirements.
Talk to an Oakland Criminal Defense Attorney About a Racial Justice Act Claim
The Nieves Law Firm handles criminal defense and post-conviction matters for clients in Oakland, the Bay Area, and beyond.
When racial bias may have affected a criminal case, the starting point is a focused review of the facts—not an assumption that the claim is automatically successful or too late to pursue.
An attorney can evaluate the alleged conduct, available evidence, relevant court records, and potential procedural options.
That review may involve determining whether the evidence supports an RJA motion, whether additional discovery is appropriate, or whether the conviction may be eligible for a post-conviction challenge.
Contact The Nieves Law Firm to schedule a consultation.
This article provides general information about California law and is not legal advice for a specific case. Eligibility, procedural requirements, and available remedies depend on the facts and applicable law.
Legally Reviewed By
Jo-Anna Nieves
California Criminal Defense Attorney | The Nieves Law Firm
Date of legal review: November 18, 2026
About the Reviewing Attorney
Jo-Anna Nieves is the founding attorney of The Nieves Law Firm, APC, and an experienced California criminal defense and trial attorney. Starting her career at the Sacramento County District Attorney’s Office, she brings extensive courtroom experience and insight into both sides of the criminal justice system. She has served as President of the Alameda County Bar Association and as a trial advocacy instructor at Stanford Law School. Admitted to practice in California and Florida, Jo-Anna focuses on protecting her clients’ rights, reputations, and futures through strategic criminal defense representation, including post-conviction matters.
View Attorney Profile — Jo-Anna Nieves
This article was legally reviewed by Jo-Anna Nieves, a California criminal defense attorney with The Nieves Law Firm. The review addressed the article’s discussion of Penal Code section 745, the Racial Justice Act’s amendments, relevant appellate decisions, and available criminal and post-conviction remedies.


