QUICK ANSWER
Under California Penal Code section 1001.95, a judge can put most misdemeanor cases on hold for up to 24 months, even over the prosecutor’s objection, while the defendant completes court-ordered conditions. If the defendant complies, the judge must dismiss the case, and the arrest is deemed never to have occurred. No guilty plea is required. Offenses requiring sex offender registration, domestic violence offenses, and stalking are excluded, and courts have held that misdemeanor DUI is not eligible.
Key Takeaways
- The judge decides, not the prosecutor. Diversion can be granted over the prosecutor’s objection. Pen. Code, § 1001.95(a).
- Up to 24 months, with conditions tailored to the defendant. Pen. Code, § 1001.95(b).
- Successful completion means mandatory dismissal. Pen. Code, § 1001.95(c).
- Three categories are excluded: sex offenses requiring registration, domestic violence, and stalking. Pen. Code, § 1001.95(e).
- Misdemeanor DUI is not eligible. Grassi v. Superior Court (2021) 73 Cal.App.5th 283.
- There is no first-offender requirement, though criminal history can affect the judge’s decision.
- Seriousness alone is not a reason to deny. A judge cannot deny diversion based only on facts built into an eligible offense. Bobo v. Appellate Division of Superior Court (2026) 120 Cal.App.5th 25.
- Inability to pay restitution because of indigence cannot block diversion. Pen. Code, § 1001.96(b).
For people facing misdemeanor charges in Oakland, Fremont, San Jose, Fairfield, Sacramento, Stockton, and across Northern California, judicial diversion can be the difference between a lifelong conviction and a dismissed case. The Nieves Law Firm evaluates every misdemeanor case for a path to dismissal, including diversion under section 1001.95.
What Is Judicial Misdemeanor Diversion?
Judicial misdemeanor diversion lets a judge pause an eligible misdemeanor case while the defendant completes court-ordered conditions, then dismiss it. Penal Code sections 1001.95 through 1001.97 were enacted by Assembly Bill 3234 (Stats. 2020, ch. 334), effective January 1, 2021.
Unlike a plea deal, it does not depend on the prosecutor’s agreement. Section 1001.95(a) says a judge may offer diversion “at the judge’s discretion, and over the objection of a prosecuting attorney.” The judge may continue the case for up to 24 months and order any terms, conditions, or programs the judge considers appropriate for the defendant’s situation. If the defendant complies, the judge must dismiss the case at the end of the diversion period.
Legal authority: Cal. Penal Code, § 1001.95(a)–(c).
PC 1001.95 Diversion at a Glance
| Question | Answer |
|---|---|
| What law authorizes it? | Penal Code § 1001.95 |
| Who decides? | The superior court judge |
| Must the prosecutor agree? | No |
| First-time offenders only? | No |
| How long does it last? | Up to 24 months |
| Is a guilty plea required? | No |
| What happens after successful completion? | The case must be dismissed and the arrest is deemed never to have occurred |
| Excluded charges | Sex offenses requiring registration, domestic violence, stalking |
| Is DUI eligible? | No (Grassi) |
Who Qualifies for Misdemeanor Diversion in California?
A defendant qualifies when the misdemeanor is not excluded by section 1001.95 or another statute, and the judge finds diversion appropriate. That is two separate questions:
1. Eligibility: Does the law allow diversion for this charge?
2. Suitability: Should this judge grant diversion to this person?
An eligible defendant can still be denied. But a defendant should not be treated as ineligible just because the offense is serious or the prosecutor objects, as the Court of Appeal emphasized in Bobo (2026).
Is PC 1001.95 Only for First-Time Offenders?
No. The statute has no first-offender requirement, so a prior record does not automatically disqualify someone. The judge may consider history, such as past compliance with court orders or completion of programs, when deciding suitability. A strong request addresses the history directly.
Which Crimes Are Excluded From PC 1001.95 Diversion?
Section 1001.95(e) bars diversion for three types of current charges:
- Sex offenses requiring registration: any offense that would require registration under Penal Code section 290 if the defendant were convicted.
- Domestic violence: any offense involving domestic violence as defined in Family Code section 6211 or Penal Code section 13700(b). The exclusion turns on the relationship and conduct, not just the name of the charge.
- Stalking: a violation of Penal Code section 646.9.
Other statutes can also block diversion even when a charge is not on this list. DUI is the main example.
Legal authority: Cal. Penal Code, § 1001.95(e); Fam. Code, § 6211; Pen. Code, § 13700(b).
Can You Get Misdemeanor Diversion for a DUI?
No. Vehicle Code section 23640 bars courts from suspending a DUI case under Vehicle Code section 23152 or 23153 so the defendant can attend a program before conviction. In Grassi v. Superior Court (2021) 73 Cal.App.5th 283, an Orange County case involving misdemeanor driving under the influence of drugs, the Court of Appeal held, as a matter of first impression, that section 1001.95 does not override that bar. Misdemeanor DUI defendants are not eligible for judicial diversion, even with no prior record. Other defenses and resolutions still need to be explored.
Legal authority: Veh. Code, § 23640; Grassi v. Superior Court (2021) 73 Cal.App.5th 283.
Can Misdemeanor Vehicular Manslaughter Qualify for Diversion?
Yes. In Bobo v. Appellate Division of Superior Court (2026) 120 Cal.App.5th 25, the Court of Appeal explained that a defendant charged with misdemeanor vehicular manslaughter under Penal Code section 192(c)(2) is eligible for diversion because that offense is not one of the excluded offenses listed in the statute.
What Did the 2026 Bobo Decision Decide?
Background. Aimee Bobo was charged in San Diego County after she ran a red light, collided with another car, and killed the other driver. Police saw no signs of intoxication. Her diversion request described her background, education, employment, and community ties. The trial court found her eligible but not suitable because of “the severe consequences” of her negligent driving, and the appellate division denied her writ petition.
Holding. The Court of Appeal granted writ relief. It held that:
- A trial court must connect the facts of the offense to the purposes of the diversion statute when deciding suitability. It cannot deny diversion based only on facts that are inherent in an eligible offense, such as the death in a vehicular manslaughter case.
- The victim’s family’s opposition and desire for a conviction did not justify denying diversion.
The court ordered the trial court to vacate its denial and reconsider Bobo’s suitability under the correct standard. It did not order that she receive diversion.
Legal authority: Bobo v. Appellate Division of Superior Court (2026) 120 Cal.App.5th 25; Pen. Code, § 1001.95.
Why Bobo Matters
- An eligible defendant is entitled to a proper exercise of discretion, not automatic approval.
- Serious consequences do not create an exclusion the Legislature did not write.
- Suitability must be measured against the purposes of the diversion statute.
- Victim opposition is not a veto.
- Writ relief can be available when a court applies the wrong standard.
Can a Judge Grant Diversion if the Prosecutor Objects?
Yes. Section 1001.95(a) expressly allows it. The prosecutor can argue against diversion based on the offense, criminal history, or public safety, but the judge has independent authority to decide. For example, if a prosecutor insists on a conviction in a misdemeanor theft case, the defense can still ask the judge for diversion.
Can a Victim Prevent Diversion?
No. Victims have important rights under article I, section 28 of the California Constitution, and their views can be considered. But in Bobo, the Court of Appeal held that the victim’s family’s wish for a conviction did not justify denying diversion to an eligible defendant.
Legal authority: Cal. Const., art. I, § 28; Bobo v. Appellate Division of Superior Court (2026) 120 Cal.App.5th 25.
How Does Judicial Misdemeanor Diversion Work?
Step 1: Confirm Eligibility
Your lawyer checks the charge against the section 1001.95(e) exclusions and other statutes like Vehicle Code section 23640.
Step 2: Build the Suitability Case
The defense gathers evidence about your background, the circumstances of the offense, rehabilitation, and a realistic plan.
Step 3: Present the Request
The defense files a written request with supporting evidence, a proposed diversion plan, and legal authority. The prosecutor may support or oppose it, and the judge decides.
Step 4: Complete the Conditions
The case is continued while you complete the conditions. The court may hold progress reviews.
Step 5: Dismissal
When you complete the conditions, the judge must dismiss the case, and the record protections of section 1001.97 apply.
Does PC 1001.95 Require a Guilty Plea?
No. It is a pretrial process that can end in dismissal without a plea or conviction. Your lawyer should still review any proposed waiver, stipulation, or agreement before you sign.
How Long Does Misdemeanor Diversion Last?
Up to 24 months. That is the maximum, not a required term, and the judge can set a shorter period. Finishing one program does not end diversion by itself; the court must find that all conditions were met.
Legal authority: Cal. Penal Code, § 1001.95(b).
What Conditions Can a Judge Impose?
Any terms, conditions, or programs the judge considers appropriate for the defendant’s situation. Common examples include counseling or treatment, anger management or theft-prevention classes, community service, restitution, stay-away or protective orders, firearm restrictions, and progress reviews.
To have the case dismissed, section 1001.96 requires the defendant to:
- Complete all conditions ordered by the court
- Make full restitution, but inability to pay because of indigence cannot be grounds to deny diversion or to find noncompliance
- Comply with any protective order, stay-away order, or order prohibiting firearm possession
Legal authority: Cal. Penal Code, §§ 1001.95(b), 1001.96.
What Does a Judge Consider When Deciding Whether to Grant Diversion?
The statute does not list factors, but after Bobo the judge must tie the decision to the purposes of diversion. Relevant evidence can include criminal history, the circumstances of the offense, rehabilitation efforts, employment or school, community involvement, family responsibilities, past compliance with court orders, treatment, restitution efforts and finances, and a realistic plan for completing diversion.
A strong request includes employment records, treatment records, character letters, evidence of rehabilitation, and a concrete plan, and it answers the prosecutor’s objections directly.
Attorney Insight: Sometimes the Best Defense Is Creating a Path to Dismissal
By Jo-Anna Nieves, Esq., Founder and Managing Attorney of The Nieves Law Firm
One lesson I’ve learned from handling criminal cases is that the prosecution’s initial offer does not have to define the outcome. When a client qualifies for judicial diversion, I want the court to understand who that person is beyond the allegation and why an opportunity to earn dismissal is appropriate.
Our firm handled a case in which a client initially faced a felony attempted robbery charge, a strike offense. Rather than simply negotiating the potential punishment, our defense team assembled a mitigation package addressing the client’s treatment and personal circumstances. The felony was dismissed, the case proceeded through misdemeanor judicial diversion, and the client ultimately completed the program and obtained dismissal.
That experience illustrates why I believe diversion must be evaluated as part of the defense strategy, not merely as an alternative offered after other negotiations fail.
The goal is not simply to avoid jail. When the facts and law support it, the goal is to avoid a conviction altogether.
The Nieves Law Firm
Your Future Is
Worth Fighting For
If you or someone you care about is facing criminal charges in the Bay Area, the next decision matters. Call us for a confidential consultation.
100% Confidential
Se Habla Español
Payment Plans Available
What Happens if You Violate Diversion Conditions?
The court must give notice and hold a hearing before ending diversion. If the court finds you did not comply, it may end diversion and resume the case. Termination is not automatic, so get legal help right away if a compliance issue comes up.
Legal authority: Cal. Penal Code, § 1001.95(d).
What Happens After You Complete Diversion?
The case is dismissed and the arrest is deemed never to have occurred. Under section 1001.97(a), you may generally say you were not arrested, and records of the arrest cannot be used without your consent in a way that could lead to denial of employment, a benefit, a license, or a certificate.
There is an exception for peace officer jobs. The Department of Justice may disclose the arrest in response to a peace officer application request, and you must disclose it if directly asked on a peace officer application.
Legal authority: Cal. Penal Code, § 1001.97(a)–(b).
Does Diversion Automatically Seal Your Arrest Record?
Not necessarily. Dismissal, the protections of section 1001.97, and formal record sealing are separate. Depending on the case, a petition to seal the arrest under Penal Code section 851.91 may provide additional protection.
Legal authority: Cal. Penal Code, §§ 1001.97, 851.91.
Diversion vs. Expungement
| Judicial Diversion (PC 1001.95) | Expungement (PC 1203.4) |
|---|---|
| Happens before conviction | Happens after conviction |
| Can end with no conviction | Dismisses a conviction that already exists |
| Requires completing diversion conditions | Requires meeting the post-conviction requirements |
| Arrest deemed never to have occurred (PC 1001.97) | Does not erase the historical fact of conviction |
Diversion avoids a conviction. Expungement cleans up one you already have.
Is Diversion the Same as a Plea Bargain?
No. A plea bargain is an agreement with the prosecutor. Judicial diversion comes from the judge’s independent authority and can be granted when the prosecutor will not agree to anything short of a conviction.
When Should You Request Diversion?
As early as possible. Section 1001.95 applies to a misdemeanor “being prosecuted,” so the request must come before the case ends in a plea or conviction. Raising it early gives your lawyer time to gather evidence and line up programs.
What If the Judge Denies Diversion?
A denial is not automatically an error, but judicial discretion has limits. If the court relied only on facts inherent in the offense, on victim opposition, or on another improper reason, a writ petition may be available, as in Bobo. These options can be time-sensitive.
Judicial Diversion vs. Mental Health and Military Diversion
| Program | Statute | Who It Is For |
|---|---|---|
| Judicial misdemeanor diversion | Pen. Code § 1001.95 | Eligible misdemeanor defendants |
| Mental health diversion | Pen. Code § 1001.36 | Misdemeanor and felony defendants with a qualifying mental health disorder |
| Military diversion | Pen. Code § 1001.80 | Current and former service members with a qualifying service-related condition, including misdemeanor DUI |
Someone who does not qualify for one program may qualify for another. For example, a veteran charged with a misdemeanor DUI cannot get section 1001.95 diversion but may qualify for military diversion.
Examples
Misdemeanor theft, no record, stable job: Eligible. A strong candidate for diversion with theft-prevention classes and restitution.
Misdemeanor vandalism: Eligible. Restitution will be addressed, with protection if the defendant is indigent.
Eligible misdemeanor with a prior conviction: Not disqualified. The judge weighs the history with everything else.
Misdemeanor DUI, no record: Not eligible under Grassi.
Misdemeanor vehicular manslaughter: Eligible under Bobo, but the judge decides suitability.
These are general illustrations, not predictions.
Frequently Asked Questions About PC 1001.95 Diversion
What is Penal Code 1001.95?
A California law that lets a judge divert an eligible misdemeanor case for up to 24 months and dismiss it if the defendant completes the conditions.
Can a misdemeanor be dismissed without a conviction in California?
Yes. Successful judicial diversion under section 1001.95 ends in dismissal with no conviction.
Can you get misdemeanor diversion with a criminal record?
Potentially. There is no first-offender requirement, though the judge can consider your history.
Can a prosecutor stop judicial diversion?
No. Section 1001.95(a) allows the judge to grant diversion over the prosecutor’s objection.
What misdemeanors do not qualify?
Offenses requiring sex offender registration, domestic violence offenses, and stalking under section 646.9. DUI is also ineligible because of Vehicle Code section 23640.
Can you get misdemeanor diversion for a DUI?
No. Grassi v. Superior Court (2021) 73 Cal.App.5th 283.
Can misdemeanor vehicular manslaughter qualify?
Yes. It is not excluded, and a judge cannot deny diversion based only on the death inherent in the offense. Bobo v. Appellate Division of Superior Court (2026) 120 Cal.App.5th 25.
How long does misdemeanor diversion last?
Up to 24 months. The judge can set a shorter period.
Do you have to plead guilty?
No. It is a pretrial process.
What if I cannot afford restitution?
Inability to pay because of indigence cannot be grounds to deny diversion or find noncompliance. Pen. Code, § 1001.96(b).
What happens if I fail diversion?
After notice and a hearing, the judge may end diversion and resume the case.
Does diversion clear my record?
The case is dismissed and the arrest is deemed never to have occurred, with an exception for peace officer applications. A separate sealing petition may add protection.
Can a victim block diversion?
No. A victim’s opposition can be considered but is not a veto.
Can a judge deny diversion because the crime was serious?
Not based only on facts inherent in an eligible offense. The court must connect its reasons to the purposes of diversion.
Can I challenge a denial?
Potentially, through a writ petition if the court applied the wrong standard, as in Bobo.
Speak With a California Criminal Defense Attorney About Misdemeanor Diversion
A misdemeanor conviction can follow you to job applications, professional licenses, and housing. Judicial diversion may let you avoid one entirely, even if the prosecutor says no.
The Nieves Law Firm represents people facing criminal charges in Oakland, Fremont, San Jose, Fairfield, Sacramento, Stockton, and throughout Northern California. Our team serves clients in English and Spanish. If you are facing a misdemeanor charge, do not assume a conviction is your only option. Contact The Nieves Law Firm or call (510) 879-7549 to schedule a consultation.
Oakland Headquarters: 160 Franklin Street, Suite 210, Oakland, CA 94607
We take the “criminal” out of criminal defense.®
Legally Reviewed By
Jo-Anna Nieves, Esq., California Criminal Defense Attorney, The Nieves Law Firm, APC
Date of legal review: November 19, 2026
About the Reviewing Attorney
Jo-Anna Nieves is the founding attorney of The Nieves Law Firm, APC, and an experienced California criminal defense and trial attorney. Starting her career at the Sacramento County District Attorney’s Office, she brings extensive courtroom experience and insight into both sides of the criminal justice system. She has served as President of the Alameda County Bar Association and as a trial advocacy instructor at Stanford Law School. Admitted to practice in California and Florida, Jo-Anna focuses on protecting her clients’ rights, reputations, and futures through strategic criminal defense representation.
View Jo-Anna Nieves’s attorney profile
This article is provided for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Reading this article or contacting the firm does not, by itself, establish an attorney-client relationship. Diversion eligibility, procedural requirements, and outcomes depend on the circumstances of each case and the law that applies.


