QUICK ANSWER

A preliminary hearing (also called a preliminary examination) is the court hearing in most California felony cases where a judge decides whether there is enough evidence to make the defendant stand trial. It is not a trial and does not decide guilt. The prosecution only has to show probable cause. The defense can cross-examine witnesses, challenge weak charges, and in limited cases present evidence. If the judge finds insufficient evidence, charges can be dismissed, though prosecutors sometimes can refile.

Key Takeaways

  • It is a screening hearing, not a trial. A judge, not a jury, decides whether there is probable cause to hold the defendant to answer.
  • The standard is low. The question is whether the evidence would lead a person of ordinary caution to strongly suspect guilt. People v. Slaughter (1984) 35 Cal.3d 629, 637.
  • It must happen fast. Generally within 10 court days of arraignment or plea, and never more than 60 days without a personal waiver. Pen. Code, § 859b.
  • Officers can testify to what others told them. Qualified officers may relate hearsay statements, so alleged victims do not always appear. Pen. Code, § 872(b).
  • Charges can be dismissed, but prosecutors may be able to refile, seek reinstatement, or add supported charges to the information.
  • A new rule starts January 1, 2027. Prosecutors who want to bring back a charge the judge dismissed for lack of probable cause will need the court’s permission first.

For anyone facing felony charges in Oakland, Alameda County, or elsewhere in Northern California, the preliminary hearing is often the first real chance to test the prosecution’s evidence, lock in witness testimony, and knock out charges that should never have been filed.

California Preliminary Hearing at a Glance

QuestionShort Answer
Is a preliminary hearing a trial?No. It is a judicial screening of felony charges.
Who decides the result?A judge sitting as a magistrate, not a jury.
What must the prosecution prove?Probable cause, far lower than proof beyond a reasonable doubt.
When is it held?Within 10 court days of arraignment or plea unless waived or continued for good cause; dismissal after 60 days without a personal waiver.
Can the defense cross-examine witnesses?Yes.
Can the defense call witnesses?Yes, if the testimony is reasonably likely to establish a defense, negate an element, or impeach a prosecution witness.
Can charges be dismissed?Yes, but dismissal does not always end the prosecution.
What does “held to answer” mean?The case moves forward. It is not a finding of guilt.
What happens next?The prosecution files an information within 15 days, followed by arraignment in superior court.

What Is the Purpose of a Preliminary Hearing?

The purpose is to decide whether there is probable cause to believe the defendant committed a felony. It keeps a felony case started by complaint from going to trial without a judge first reviewing the evidence. The statute also says the hearing is not to be used for discovery.

California courts describe probable cause as evidence that would lead a person of ordinary caution or prudence to believe and conscientiously entertain a strong suspicion of the defendant’s guilt. People v. Slaughter (1984) 35 Cal.3d 629, 637. That is not a finding of guilt. The prosecution can win at this stage even when serious factual disputes remain for a jury.

Legal authority: Cal. Penal Code, §§ 866(b), 872(a); People v. Slaughter (1984) 35 Cal.3d 629, 637.

How Is a Preliminary Hearing Different From a Trial?

At trial, the prosecution must prove every element beyond a reasonable doubt to a jury. At a preliminary hearing, it only has to show probable cause to a judge. Witnesses testify under oath and can be cross-examined, but there is no verdict.

The evidence rules are also looser. A qualified law enforcement officer can testify about what witnesses or alleged victims told them, which usually would not be allowed through that officer at trial.

Being held to answer does not mean the prosecution has proven anything, that the defense has lost, or that all of the evidence will be admissible at trial.

Legal authority: Cal. Penal Code, § 872(b).

When Must a Preliminary Hearing Be Held in California?

Penal Code section 859b sets two deadlines.

The 10-court-day rule. Both the defendant and the prosecution have the right to a preliminary hearing at the earliest possible time. Unless both sides waive that right or the court finds good cause for a continuance, the hearing must be held within 10 court days of arraignment or plea, whichever is later. If the defendant has been in custody for 10 or more court days solely on that complaint, the court must dismiss the complaint if the hearing is set or continued past that period, unless the defendant personally waives the right or the prosecution shows good cause. In many of those situations, the defendant must be released.

The 60-day rule. The court must dismiss the complaint if the hearing is set or continued more than 60 days from arraignment or plea, unless the defendant personally waives the 60-day right.

These are court days, not calendar days. Whether a deadline was violated depends on the exact dates, custody status, waivers, and continuances.

Legal authority: Cal. Penal Code, § 859b.

Should You Waive Time for Your Preliminary Hearing?

Not automatically. Waiving time can give the defense room to get discovery, interview witnesses, and review forensic evidence. It can also delay an important hearing and give up a protection that could lead to dismissal or release. The decision should be made with your lawyer based on the facts of your case.

What Happens Before the Preliminary Hearing?

Most felony cases start with an arraignment, where the defendant is told the charges, enters a plea, and bail or release conditions are addressed. See our guide to your first court appearance in California.

Before the hearing, the defense reviews police reports, body-camera and surveillance video, witness statements, digital and forensic evidence, and the legal elements of every charge. That preparation decides whether to cross-examine aggressively, call a witness, bring a motion to suppress, or preserve an issue for later.

What Happens During a California Preliminary Hearing?

1. The Prosecution Presents Evidence

The prosecutor calls witnesses such as officers, investigators, eyewitnesses, or the alleged victim. The prosecution does not have to present its whole trial case, only enough to show probable cause.

2. The Defense Cross-Examines Witnesses

Defense counsel can question witnesses about identification, inconsistencies, gaps in the investigation, timelines, and bias. Cross-examination can show that an element of a charge is missing. The testimony is under oath and recorded, so it can be used later to impeach a witness whose trial testimony changes.

3. The Defense May Present Limited Evidence

The defense can call witnesses, but if the prosecutor asks, the defense must make an offer of proof. The judge allows the testimony only if it is reasonably likely to establish an affirmative defense, negate an element of a charged crime, or impeach a prosecution witness or a statement a prosecution witness relayed. Because the hearing cannot be used for discovery, calling witnesses is a strategic decision.

Legal authority: Cal. Penal Code, § 866(a)–(b).

4. The Lawyers Argue Probable Cause

Counsel argue whether the evidence supports each charge and allegation. The strongest defense arguments point to a specific missing element or legal defect, not just a witness’s credibility.

5. The Judge Rules

The judge may hold the defendant to answer on all charges, some charges, or none. Each count can be decided separately.

Can a Felony Charge Be Dismissed at the Preliminary Hearing?

Yes. If the judge finds insufficient cause, the defendant is discharged on the complaint, or the judge declines to hold the defendant on particular charges.

Dismissal does not always end the case. Depending on the circumstances, the prosecutor may file a new complaint, seek a grand jury indictment, move to reinstate the complaint under Penal Code section 871.5, or include charges supported by the evidence in the information under section 739. Penal Code section 1387 limits how many times a case can be refiled, with exceptions. Whether the case can lawfully continue depends on whether the judge made a factual finding or a legal ruling, the evidence, and the case history.

Legal authority: Cal. Penal Code, §§ 739, 871, 871.5, 1387.

Case Result: 23 Felony Counts Challenged at the Preliminary Hearing

The Nieves Law Firm defended a client charged with 23 felony counts, including rape, sodomy, oral copulation, and domestic violence, and successfully challenged all 23 counts at the preliminary hearing stage. The case ultimately resolved as a single accessory-after-the-fact charge under Penal Code section 32, which was reduced to a misdemeanor. Read the 23-felony-count case result.

Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Every case depends on its own evidence, charges, procedural history, and the law.

Can the Prosecutor Refile Charges After a Dismissal?

Sometimes. Under Penal Code section 871.5, the prosecutor can move in superior court within 15 days to reinstate a dismissed complaint or count, but only if the dismissal was erroneous as a matter of law. Section 1387 limits successive prosecutions after prior dismissals, subject to exceptions. Your lawyer should review the dismissal order, any prior dismissals, and the prosecutor’s next step.

Legal authority: Cal. Penal Code, §§ 871.5, 1387.

New in 2027: The Respect Judicial Decisions Act

Starting January 1, 2027, prosecutors will need court permission to bring back a felony count a judge dismissed at the preliminary hearing for lack of probable cause. Assembly Bill 1917 (Stats. 2026, ch. 376), filed with the Secretary of State on September 20, 2026, adds Penal Code section 995(c). It applies when the defendant was held to answer on at least one felony count at a preliminary hearing held on or after January 1, 2027:

  • Before filing an information that reinstates a dismissed count, the district attorney must file a motion for leave to charge it, within the 15-day deadline for filing the information.
  • The court may grant the motion only if it finds the offense was committed and there is sufficient probable cause to believe the defendant is guilty.
  • If the motion is granted, the defense cannot use a section 995 motion to challenge the reinstated count for lack of probable cause. Instead, the defense may seek a writ of prohibition in the Court of Appeal within 15 days of the ruling.
  • Any request for pretrial review of the ruling must be made within 60 days of arraignment on the information or indictment, unless the defense was unaware of the issue or had no opportunity to raise it.

The Legislature stated that the new rule applies only to cases where the preliminary hearing occurs on or after January 1, 2027. It is not in effect as of this November 2026 update.

Legal authority: AB 1917 (Stats. 2026, ch. 376), amending Cal. Penal Code, §§ 739, 995, 999a, 1510, operative Jan. 1, 2027.

Can a Felony Be Reduced to a Misdemeanor Before Trial?

Yes, if the offense is a wobbler. Wobblers can be charged as either a felony or a misdemeanor. Since January 1, 2026, Penal Code section 17(b)(5)(A) lets the court decide before trial, on its own motion or a party’s motion, that a wobbler is a misdemeanor. If that motion is denied, a new motion requires a showing of changed circumstances, such as new facts about the charge or the defendant’s personal circumstances, or a change in the law.

Not every felony is a wobbler, and the court has discretion. Learn more about misdemeanor versus felony charges in California.

Legal authority: Cal. Penal Code, § 17(b)(5)(A)–(B).

Can Police Officers Testify About What Someone Else Said?

Yes. Under Penal Code section 872(b), the judge can find probable cause based in whole or in part on a qualified officer’s sworn testimony about out-of-court statements. The officer must meet experience or training requirements, and an honorably retired officer may relate only statements made while they were still active. As a result, alleged victims and eyewitnesses do not always have to testify at a preliminary hearing. This rule does not make all hearsay admissible and does not apply at trial.

Legal authority: Cal. Penal Code, § 872(b).

The Nieves Law Firm

Your Future Is
Worth Fighting For

If you or someone you care about is facing criminal charges in the Bay Area, the next decision matters. Call us for a confidential consultation.

Call (510) 879-7549

100% Confidential

Se Habla Español

Payment Plans Available

Does the Defendant Testify at the Preliminary Hearing?

Usually not, and the defendant cannot be forced to. The privilege against self-incrimination applies, and testifying can create statements that hurt the defense later. Most challenges are made through cross-examination of the prosecution’s witnesses.

Can the Defense Move to Suppress Evidence at the Preliminary Hearing?

Yes. A motion to suppress under Penal Code section 1538.5 can be heard at the preliminary hearing, limited to evidence the prosecution offers at that hearing. It must be filed and personally served at least five court days before the hearing, with a memorandum of points and authorities. The judge may grant a continuance if the defense was not aware of the evidence or grounds earlier. The motion can also be made or renewed later in superior court, but if it was litigated at the preliminary hearing, the later hearing is generally limited to the preliminary hearing transcript plus evidence that could not reasonably have been presented earlier.

Legal authority: Cal. Penal Code, § 1538.5(f), (i).

What Happens After a Defendant Is Held to Answer?

The prosecution files an information within 15 days, and the defendant is arraigned on it in superior court. The information can charge the offenses named in the holding order or other offenses shown by the evidence at the preliminary hearing. Beginning with preliminary hearings held on or after January 1, 2027, that power is subject to the new section 995(c) leave-of-court requirement for counts the judge dismissed for lack of probable cause.

This is why a count missing from the holding order may still reappear, and why the defense reviews the entire preliminary hearing record.

Legal authority: Cal. Penal Code, § 739 (as amended by AB 1917, operative Jan. 1, 2027).

What Is a Penal Code Section 995 Motion?

A 995 motion asks the superior court to set aside an information, in whole or in part, because the defendant was not legally committed or was committed without reasonable or probable cause. It reviews the preliminary hearing record; it is not a second trial. Being held to answer does not end the defense’s ability to challenge whether the case can legally proceed.

Legal authority: Cal. Penal Code, § 995(a)(2).

Can a Preliminary Hearing Be Waived?

Yes. A defendant can waive the preliminary hearing, usually with advice of counsel and often as part of a negotiated resolution. Waiving lets the prosecution proceed without presenting evidence at an examination, so it should not be done just because the prosecution will probably meet the low standard.

Not every felony case has a preliminary hearing. Cases started by grand jury indictment follow a different procedure without a preliminary examination.

How Long Does a Preliminary Hearing Take?

It varies. A hearing with one or two officer witnesses relying on hearsay testimony can be short. Cases with many counts, forensic issues, multiple defendants, or contested cross-examination can take longer and may continue over more than one day.

Should the Defense Always Fight Every Charge at the Preliminary Hearing?

Not always. Targeted cross-examination can expose weaknesses, lock in testimony, knock out a charge, and improve plea negotiations. Excessive questioning or unnecessary defense witnesses can reveal strategy without improving the client’s position. The preliminary hearing is one stage of the overall defense and should be handled as part of that plan.

Attorney Insight: A Preliminary Hearing Can Change the Direction of a Felony Case

By Jo-Anna Nieves, Esq., Founder and Managing Attorney of The Nieves Law Firm

One of the most important strategic decisions in a felony case is whether to proceed with a contested preliminary hearing, what testimony to challenge, and what the defense hopes to accomplish.

A preliminary hearing is not a trial, and the prosecution’s burden is significantly lower. But that does not mean the proceeding lacks strategic value.

Our firm handled a serious felony case involving homicide-related allegations in which the defense pursued release through bail litigation, obtained additional records, reviewed extensive video evidence, and cross-examined investigating officers and a complaining witness during a contested preliminary hearing. The prosecution ultimately dismissed all charges.

That experience illustrates why a preliminary hearing can be more than a probable cause determination. The defense may use the proceeding to expose weaknesses, obtain testimony under oath, narrow disputed issues, or improve its position for later litigation and negotiations.

Of course, not every preliminary hearing should be contested in the same manner.

The strategic question is whether the hearing will leave the client in a stronger position than before, even if the judge ultimately holds the defendant to answer.

Frequently Asked Questions About California Preliminary Hearings

What is a preliminary hearing in California?

A hearing in most felony cases where a judge decides whether there is probable cause to make the defendant stand trial. It is not a trial and does not decide guilt.

Does everyone charged with a felony get a preliminary hearing?

No. Felony cases started by complaint generally have one, but the defendant can waive it, resolve the case first, or be charged by grand jury indictment instead.

How soon must a preliminary hearing be held in California?

Generally within 10 court days of arraignment or plea, unless both sides waive or there is good cause. The complaint must be dismissed if the hearing is set or continued more than 60 days out without a personal waiver. Pen. Code, § 859b.

What is the standard of proof at a preliminary hearing?

Probable cause: enough evidence to lead a person of ordinary caution to entertain a strong suspicion of guilt. It is much lower than proof beyond a reasonable doubt.

Do victims have to testify at a preliminary hearing?

Not always. Under Penal Code section 872(b), a qualified officer can testify about what the alleged victim said.

Can charges be dismissed at a preliminary hearing?

Yes. The judge can dismiss the whole complaint or individual counts if the evidence is insufficient, though prosecutors may sometimes refile or seek reinstatement.

Can the judge dismiss just one felony count?

Yes. The judge can hold the defendant to answer on some counts and dismiss others.

What changes for preliminary hearings in 2027?

For preliminary hearings on or after January 1, 2027, prosecutors must get court permission before reinstating a count the judge dismissed for lack of probable cause when the defendant was held to answer on at least one felony. AB 1917, the Respect Judicial Decisions Act.

Can I go to jail after a preliminary hearing?

A preliminary hearing is not a sentencing. Custody and bail are handled separately, though they may be revisited as the case moves forward.

Can a felony be reduced to a misdemeanor at the preliminary hearing stage?

If the offense is a wobbler, the court can reduce it to a misdemeanor before trial under Penal Code section 17(b)(5).

Is the preliminary hearing the last chance to get charges dismissed?

No. A Penal Code section 995 motion, a motion to suppress, and other motions can still challenge the case afterward.

Can a case end with a plea deal at the preliminary hearing stage?

Yes. Many cases are negotiated before, during, or right after the preliminary hearing.

Talk to an Oakland Felony Defense Attorney About Your Preliminary Hearing

The preliminary hearing comes quickly and can shape everything that follows: which charges survive, what witnesses say under oath, and how much leverage you have in negotiations. Preparing for it early makes a difference.

The Nieves Law Firm defends clients facing felony charges in Oakland, Alameda County, and across Northern California, with offices in Oakland, Fremont, Fairfield, Sacramento, and Stockton. Our team serves clients in English and Spanish. If you are facing felony charges or have a preliminary hearing coming up, contact The Nieves Law Firm to discuss your defense.

Legally Reviewed By

Jo-Anna Nieves, Esq., California Criminal Defense Attorney, The Nieves Law Firm, APC

Date of legal review: November 19, 2026

About the Reviewing Attorney

Jo-Anna Nieves is the founding attorney of The Nieves Law Firm, APC, and an experienced California criminal defense and trial attorney. Starting her career at the Sacramento County District Attorney’s Office, she brings extensive courtroom experience and insight into both sides of the criminal justice system. She has served as President of the Alameda County Bar Association and as a trial advocacy instructor at Stanford Law School. Admitted to practice in California and Florida, Jo-Anna focuses on protecting her clients’ rights, reputations, and futures through strategic criminal defense representation.

View Jo-Anna Nieves’s attorney profile

This article provides general information about California criminal procedure, not legal advice for a particular case. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws and procedures change, and outcomes depend on the facts and procedural history. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.