Call Us Today - It's Free! Text Us
Text Us

The Role of Self-Defense in Domestic Violence Defense


You’re sitting there, your heart pounding in your chest as you face accusations of domestic violence. You know that what transpired was far from simple aggression – it was a desperate act of self-defense.

It’s an agonizing situation to be in, where the lines between victim and accused get blurred. Understanding the role of self-defense in such cases is crucial, not only for your legal defense but also for your peace of mind.

What is Self-Defense?

Self-defense is an affirmative defense in the context of domestic violence charges. It refers to the use of force by a defendant to protect themselves against an immediate threat or harm from their partner or family member. A criminal defense attorney can help prove self-defense by arguing that the defendant acted in self-defense and that their actions were justified under the circumstances. It can be hard to prove self-defense as the burden of proof lies with the defendant.

However, an experienced attorney can provide a defense to successfully claim self-defense. The jury must determine whether a reasonable person in the defendant’s position would have believed that force was necessary to protect themselves. It is important to note that self-defense does not apply if the defendant instigated the altercation or used more force than necessary. If the defendant can prove their actions were justified, they may be acquitted of the criminal charges.

When Can You Claim Self-Defense in a Domestic Violence Case?

In a domestic violence case, you’re justified in using self-defense when you genuinely believe that there’s immediate danger of physical harm and you’ve used no more force than was reasonably necessary to protect yourself.

Reasonable Belief of an Imminent Threat or Bodily Injury

The ‘reasonable person’ standard is often applied in domestic violence cases involving self-defense. It means that if any reasonable person in your position would have thought they were under immediate threat and acted the same way you did, then your actions could be seen as justifiable self-defense in a court of law.

However, it’s important to remember that what constitutes an ‘immediate threat’ can vary based on the circumstances and from one jurisdiction to another. For example, if there’s a pattern of ongoing abuse but no physical assault at the time of your defensive action, some courts may not view this as an imminent danger warranting self-defense.

Reasonable Belief That Immediate Use of Force is Necessary

In the context of self-defense, you must also show that it was immediately necessary to use force in order to protect yourself or someone else from a perceived danger. Your belief in the need for immediate action is based on what is reasonably perceived as a threat to your or someone else’s safety or well-being.

The Use of Force Was Reasonable

You also need to prove that the level of force used was proportionate to the perceived threat — for instance, employing deadly force might not be deemed reasonable if you were only being threatened verbally. Navigating these complexities requires understanding how self-defense laws apply specifically to domestic violence cases and having an empathetic advocate who can navigate these issues on your behalf.

Is There a Duty to Retreat in California?

In California, you have no legal obligation to retreat before using force in self-defense, even in your home.

Of course, this only applies if you reasonably believe you’re in imminent danger of being physically harmed. The law recognizes the immediacy and intensity of domestic violence situations and acknowledges that victims often don’t have the luxury of time or space to retreat.

However, it’s not an open-and-shut case when asserting a self-defense claim during a domestic violence defense. Engaging with an experienced attorney can help navigate these complexities for successful defense strategy planning.

How to Prove Self-Defense in Domestic Violence Situations

If you’re fighting a domestic abuse case, the first step is typically retaining an experienced defense lawyer who knows the ins and outs of these cases. They can help gather evidence, interview witnesses, and present a compelling argument that you acted in self-defense during the incident.

Your defense lawyer will likely focus on certain key points:

  • Demonstrating there was an immediate threat to your safety or life
  • Showing that you believed force was necessary to protect yourself
  • Ensuring that the amount of force used is aligned with the perceived threat, and
  • Confirming there wasn’t a reasonable opportunity for retreat or escape from the situation

Any prior instances where your abuser threatened or hurt you can also serve as powerful ammunition in establishing a pattern of violence – further bolstering your claim of acting in self-defense during this particular instance.

Remember, it’s not about denying responsibility for what happened—it’s about affirming that anyone would have acted similarly under such dire circumstances.

Contact The Nieves Law Firm for Domestic Violence Defense

If you have been charged with domestic violence charge resulting from self-defense, contacting The Nieves Law Firm is the smartest decision you’d make. Our firm focuses on domestic violence defense and understands the complexities of these cases.

Our criminal defense attorneys will guide you through the judicial process, ensuring your rights are protected. We understand how self-defense plays into domestic violence cases and can help build a strong case for you.
Contact us today and schedule a consultation.

Author Bio

Jo-Anna Nieves is the Founder and Managing Attorney of The Nieves Law Firm, an Oakland criminal defense law firm she created in 2012. With more than 11 years of experience in criminal defense, she has zealously represented clients in a wide range of legal matters, including DUIs, domestic violence, expungement, federal crimes, juvenile law, motions to vacate, sex crimes, violent crimes, and other criminal charges.

Jo-Anna received her Juris Doctor from the Florida State University College of Law and is a member of the State Bar of California. She has received numerous accolades for her work, including being named a Super Lawyer Rising Star the past 8 years, the #12 Fastest Growing Law Firm in the U.S. by Law Firm 500 in 2019, and one of the fastest growing companies in the U.S. by Inc 5000 in 2023.

LinkedIn | State Bar Association | Avvo | Google