QUICK ANSWER

A wobbler is a California crime that can be charged and punished as either a felony or a misdemeanor, such as assault with a deadly weapon (Penal Code 245(a)(1)), criminal threats (422), felony vandalism (594(b)(1)), and corporal injury to a spouse or partner (273.5). Under Penal Code section 17(b), a wobbler can become a misdemeanor if the prosecutor files it that way, if the judge reduces it, or after conviction in some cases. Since January 1, 2026, AB 321 lets a judge reduce a wobbler to a misdemeanor at any time before trial, not just at the preliminary hearing.

Key Takeaways

  • A felony charge does not have to end in a felony conviction if the offense is a wobbler.
  • Since January 1, 2026, judges can reduce a wobbler any time before trial, on their own motion or either side’s motion. AB 321 (Stats. 2025, ch. 611).
  • The prosecutor does not have to agree, but can oppose the reduction.
  • A second pretrial request requires changed circumstances, so the first motion should be well prepared.
  • Felony convictions can sometimes be reduced later under section 17(b)(3) when probation was granted.
  • Unpaid restitution cannot be the reason a reduction is denied. Pen. Code, § 17(f).
  • A later reduction does not erase a strike, and it does not end sex offender registration.

For anyone facing felony charges in Oakland, the Bay Area, Sacramento, Fairfield, or elsewhere in Northern California, knowing whether the charge is a wobbler, and when to ask for a reduction, can change the sentencing exposure and the long-term consequences for work, licensing, and family.

What Is the Difference Between a Felony, Misdemeanor, and Wobbler?

California crimes are felonies, misdemeanors, or infractions. A wobbler is not a separate category; it is an offense the law allows to be treated as either a felony or a misdemeanor.

ClassificationMeaningPossible Consequences
FelonyPunishable by state prison or county jail under § 1170(h)Prison or felony jail term, plus long-term consequences
MisdemeanorEvery other crime that is not an infractionFines, probation, and up to 364 days in county jail in most cases
WobblerPunishable as either a felony or a misdemeanorDepends on how it is charged, reduced, or sentenced
InfractionLowest-level violationUsually a fine, no jail

Under Penal Code section 17(a), a felony is a crime punishable by death, state prison, or county jail under section 1170(h). Under section 18.5, an offense punishable by up to one year in county jail is capped at 364 days, though some misdemeanors carry lower maximums. Whether a charge is a wobbler depends on the statute’s wording, not just how the prosecutor filed it. See our guide to the difference between a misdemeanor and a felony.

Legal authority: Cal. Penal Code, §§ 17(a), 18.5.

What Crimes Are Wobblers in California?

Common wobblers include:

OffenseStatutePunishment Range
Assault with a deadly weapon other than a firearmPen. Code § 245(a)(1)State prison 2, 3, or 4 years, or county jail up to one year
Assault with force likely to produce great bodily injuryPen. Code § 245(a)(4)State prison 2, 3, or 4 years, or county jail up to one year
Criminal threatsPen. Code § 422(a)County jail up to one year or state prison
Vandalism of $400 or morePen. Code § 594(b)(1)Jail under § 1170(h) or county jail up to one year
Corporal injury to a spouse or intimate partnerPen. Code § 273.5(a)State prison 2, 3, or 4 years, or county jail up to one year

This is not a complete list, and not every subsection of a statute is a wobbler. For example, some subdivisions of section 245 carry only felony punishment. An attorney must check the exact charge and subsection.

Example: Assault With a Deadly Weapon

Someone is charged with felony assault with a deadly weapon other than a firearm under section 245(a)(1). Because that subdivision allows either state prison or up to a year in county jail, it is a wobbler. The defense can investigate the weapon, the injury, the circumstances, and the client’s history, and ask the court to treat the charge as a misdemeanor. The court does not have to agree, but the law gives it that power.

Example: Felony Vandalism

Someone is accused of causing more than $400 in damage. Under section 594(b)(1), that is a wobbler. The defense can challenge the damage estimate and who caused the damage, which is a question of proof, and separately ask for misdemeanor treatment under section 17(b).

What Is Penal Code Section 17(b)?

Penal Code section 17(b) lists the ways a wobbler becomes a misdemeanor “for all purposes.”

  • § 17(b)(1): The judgment imposes a punishment other than state prison or county jail under section 1170(h).
  • § 17(b)(2): A juvenile court designates the offense a misdemeanor when committing a youth to a secure youth treatment facility.
  • § 17(b)(3): The court grants probation and declares the offense a misdemeanor, either then or later on application of the defendant or probation officer.
  • § 17(b)(4): The prosecutor files the offense as a misdemeanor. If the defendant objects at arraignment or plea, the complaint is amended back to a felony.
  • § 17(b)(5): The court determines before trial that the offense is a misdemeanor.

These routes are not interchangeable. Someone with a pending felony may ask for a pretrial reduction. Someone already convicted needs to look at the judgment, the sentence, and the probation history.

Legal authority: Cal. Penal Code, § 17(b).

How Did AB 321 Change Wobbler Reductions in 2026?

AB 321 (Stats. 2025, ch. 611), effective January 1, 2026, lets the court reduce an eligible wobbler to a misdemeanor at any time before trial. Before AB 321, section 17(b)(5) allowed a magistrate to make that determination only at or before the preliminary examination or before filing the holding order under section 872.

Under the amended section 17(b)(5)(A), the court may determine before trial, on its own motion or the motion of either party, that the offense is a misdemeanor, and the case then proceeds as if the defendant had been arraigned on a misdemeanor complaint.

That matters because cases change after the preliminary hearing. The defense may get more discovery, interview witnesses, review forensic evidence, or build mitigation that supports a reduction.

AB 321 does not automatically convert charges, make every felony eligible, require judges to grant requests, prevent the prosecution from opposing, or dismiss any charge. See the Judicial Branch’s summary of new 2026 laws.

Legal authority: Cal. Penal Code, § 17(b)(5) (as amended by Stats. 2025, ch. 611).

Can a Judge Reduce a Felony to a Misdemeanor Before Trial?

Yes, if the offense is a wobbler, and the prosecutor does not have to agree. Section 17(b)(5)(A) lets the court act on its own motion or on a party’s motion. The prosecutor can argue the charge should stay a felony based on the facts, criminal history, or public safety, and the court decides. A reduction changes how the charge is classified; it does not dismiss it or decide guilt. In a multi-count case, each charge is evaluated separately.

Can You File Another 17(b) Motion If the First One Is Denied?

Yes, but only with changed circumstances. Under section 17(b)(5)(B), a later motion after a denial requires a showing of changed circumstances, which includes newly available facts about the charge or the defendant’s personal circumstances, or a change in the law. Repeating the same motion is not enough, which is why the timing and preparation of the first motion matter.

Legal authority: Cal. Penal Code, § 17(b)(5)(B).

Should You File a 17(b) Motion as Early as Possible?

Not necessarily. If the defense already has strong evidence, filing early may make sense. In other cases, it is better to get discovery, interview witnesses, and build mitigation first, because a second motion requires changed circumstances.

What Factors Does a Judge Consider?

Judges have broad discretion, but they must make an individualized decision about the offense, the offender, and the public interest. In People v. Superior Court (Alvarez) (1997) 14 Cal.4th 968, the defendant had four prior strike convictions, and the trial court reduced his wobbler to a misdemeanor at sentencing. The California Supreme Court held that courts keep their section 17(b) discretion even in Three Strikes cases, and identified the relevant factors:

  • The nature and circumstances of the offense
  • The defendant’s appreciation of and attitude toward the offense
  • The defendant’s character traits, as shown by behavior and demeanor
  • The general sentencing objectives in the California Rules of Court
  • Public safety and the defendant’s criminal history

Alvarez involved a reduction at sentencing, before AB 321, but courts continue to use it as the leading guide to section 17(b) discretion.

Legal authority: People v. Superior Court (Alvarez) (1997) 14 Cal.4th 968, 978–980.

What Evidence Helps a 17(b) Motion?

Evidence that shows who the client is and what really happened. Helpful materials can include employment records, school enrollment or achievements, treatment and rehabilitation records, medical or mental health documentation, proof of compliance with court orders, character letters, community involvement, evidence about the actual circumstances of the offense, and restitution or repair efforts. A clean record helps but does not guarantee a reduction.

Under section 17(f), an unpaid restitution order or restitution fine cannot be the basis for denying a reduction.

Legal authority: Cal. Penal Code, § 17(f).

Attorney Insight: Why a Felony Reduction Should Be Part of a Bigger Strategy

By Jo-Anna Nieves, Esq., Founder and Managing Attorney of The Nieves Law Firm

One of the most important things I consider when evaluating a felony reduction is whether we can accomplish more than simply changing the classification of the conviction. Sometimes the strongest strategy involves pursuing several forms of post-conviction relief together.

In one Alameda County case, our firm represented a client who was still on felony probation and subject to travel restrictions. Rather than simply seeking a misdemeanor reduction, our defense team filed a combined motion requesting early termination of probation under Penal Code section 1203.3, reduction of the felony under section 17(b), and dismissal under section 1203.4. We presented evidence of completed community service, secured the prosecution’s agreement, and the court granted all three requests at the same hearing.

I also believe it is important not to treat a person’s criminal history as the end of the analysis. Under People v. Superior Court (Alvarez) (1997) 14 Cal.4th 968, courts exercising discretion under section 17(b) must consider individualized factors, including the circumstances of the offense, the defendant’s attitude, character, criminal history, and public safety.

A felony reduction should never be evaluated in isolation. The goal is to identify every form of relief available and present the strongest possible case for why the client’s present circumstances justify it.

The Nieves Law Firm

Your Future Is
Worth Fighting For

If you or someone you care about is facing criminal charges in the Bay Area, the next decision matters. Call us for a confidential consultation.

Call (510) 879-7549

100% Confidential

Se Habla Español

Payment Plans Available

Can a Felony Be Reduced to a Misdemeanor After Conviction?

Sometimes. If the court granted probation, section 17(b)(3) lets it declare the offense a misdemeanor at that time or later, on application of the defendant or probation officer. You do not always have to finish probation first, though good performance on probation helps. Someone who was sentenced to state prison generally cannot use section 17(b)(3). Completing probation does not automatically reduce the felony; a motion is required. Learn more about how to get a felony reduced to a misdemeanor.

The Nieves Law Firm handles post-conviction 17(b) reductions and 1203.4 dismissals as part of our record clean-up practice.

Is a 17(b) Reduction the Same as an Expungement?

No. A 17(b) reduction changes a felony to a misdemeanor. An “expungement” usually means a dismissal under Penal Code section 1203.4. Many people qualify for both, and they are often filed together.

17(b) Reduction1203.4 Dismissal (Expungement)
Changes a felony to a misdemeanorWithdraws the plea or verdict and dismisses the case
Available before trial or after conviction in some casesAvailable after conviction once statutory requirements are met
Does not dismiss the caseDoes not reduce a felony to a misdemeanor
Does not remove every consequenceDoes not erase every record or consequence

The California courts’ Clean Your Record page explains these options for self-represented people.

What a Wobbler Reduction Does Not Do

It does not remove a strike. In People v. Park (2013) 56 Cal.4th 782, the defendant’s prior assault with a deadly weapon conviction had been reduced to a misdemeanor under section 17(b)(3) and dismissed under section 1203.4. The California Supreme Court held the reduced prior could not be used for a five-year serious felony enhancement under section 667(a). But the Court explained that the Three Strikes law is different: whether a prior counts as a strike is determined as of the date of the prior conviction and is not affected by the sentence, unless the initial sentence itself made the offense a misdemeanor. A wobbler reduced after initial sentencing can therefore still count as a strike.

Legal authority: People v. Park (2013) 56 Cal.4th 782; Pen. Code, §§ 667(d)(1), 1170.12(b)(1).

It does not end sex offender registration. Section 17(e) says the statute does not allow a judge to relieve a defendant of the duty to register under section 290 when the defendant was found guilty of an offense requiring registration.

Legal authority: Cal. Penal Code, § 17(e).

It does not automatically restore gun rights. Some misdemeanors carry their own firearm bans, and federal law has separate rules. Firearm eligibility must be checked separately.

It does not guarantee immigration protection. Federal immigration law looks at the elements of the offense, the record of conviction, and the sentence. Non-citizens should get immigration-informed advice before any plea.

It does not erase court history. Records may still show the original felony charge, and some laws preserve felony consequences even after reduction.

Why Early Legal Representation Matters in a Wobbler Case

The fight is not only over guilt; it is also over whether the case should be a felony at all. An experienced defense lawyer will confirm the charge is a wobbler, test the prosecution’s evidence, gather mitigation, decide when to file a 17(b) motion, negotiate with the prosecutor over how the case is charged, and weigh the long-term consequences of each possible outcome. Sometimes the right goal is dismissal or acquittal. Sometimes it is a misdemeanor.

Frequently Asked Questions About California Wobblers

What does wobbler mean in California?

A crime that California law allows to be treated as either a felony or a misdemeanor.

Is every felony a wobbler?

No. Only offenses whose statute allows both felony and misdemeanor punishment are wobblers. Straight felonies cannot be reduced under section 17(b).

Can a prosecutor charge a wobbler as a misdemeanor?

Yes. Under section 17(b)(4), the prosecutor can file it as a misdemeanor.

Can a judge reduce a felony without the prosecutor’s agreement?

Yes. Under section 17(b)(5)(A), the court can reduce a wobbler before trial on its own motion or either party’s motion.

What is AB 321?

A California law effective January 1, 2026 (Stats. 2025, ch. 611) that lets judges reduce an eligible wobbler to a misdemeanor at any time before trial.

Can I file a 17(b) motion after my preliminary hearing?

Yes. Since January 1, 2026, pretrial reduction requests are no longer limited to the preliminary hearing stage.

Can I file a second 17(b) motion if the first was denied?

Only with changed circumstances, such as new facts about the charge or your circumstances, or a change in the law.

Can a felony be reduced after a guilty plea?

Potentially. If you were granted probation, section 17(b)(3) allows a later request. It depends on the offense and sentence.

Do I have to finish probation before asking for a 17(b) reduction?

Not always. The court can reduce the offense when granting probation or later on application.

Can unpaid restitution stop a 17(b) reduction?

No. Section 17(f) says unpaid restitution cannot be a reason to deny a reduction.

Can I get a 17(b) reduction with prior convictions?

Yes, potentially. Priors do not take away the court’s discretion, though they weigh in the decision. People v. Superior Court (Alvarez) (1997) 14 Cal.4th 968.

Does a 17(b) reduction dismiss my case?

No. It changes the classification. Dismissal, such as under section 1203.4, is a separate process.

Will a misdemeanor reduction remove a strike?

Generally not if the reduction happens after initial sentencing. People v. Park (2013) 56 Cal.4th 782.

Can a wobbler still mean jail time?

Yes. A misdemeanor can carry up to 364 days in county jail in most cases. Pen. Code, § 18.5.

Speak With a California Criminal Defense Attorney About Your Wobbler Charge

A felony charge does not have to become a felony conviction. If your charge is a wobbler, the timing and strength of a 17(b) request can make the difference, and AB 321 gives the defense more time to build it.

The Nieves Law Firm represents people facing criminal charges in Oakland, the Bay Area, Sacramento, and across Northern California, with offices in Oakland, Fremont, Fairfield, Sacramento, and Stockton. Our team serves clients in English and Spanish. If you are facing a wobbler charge or think an old felony may qualify for reduction, contact The Nieves Law Firm for an individualized review.

We take the “criminal” out of criminal defense.®

Legally Reviewed By

Jo-Anna Nieves, Esq., California Criminal Defense Attorney, The Nieves Law Firm, APC

Date of legal review: November 19, 2026

About the Reviewing Attorney

Jo-Anna Nieves is the founding attorney of The Nieves Law Firm, APC, and an experienced California criminal defense and trial attorney. Starting her career at the Sacramento County District Attorney’s Office, she brings extensive courtroom experience and insight into both sides of the criminal justice system. She has served as President of the Alameda County Bar Association and as a trial advocacy instructor at Stanford Law School. Admitted to practice in California and Florida, Jo-Anna focuses on protecting her clients’ rights, reputations, and futures through strategic criminal defense representation.

View Jo-Anna Nieves’s attorney profile

This article is provided for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Reading this article or contacting The Nieves Law Firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Laws, procedural requirements, and available remedies depend on individual circumstances and may change.